When the choice of your perfect cooler comes down to the Yeti cooler vs. Pelican then it is time to weigh their benefits and drawbacks each to find out which cooler will suit your needs the most. In order to do so, we have crafted this guide that examines both brands and their tendencies to give you what you need in your outdoor sports or adventure and travel cooler.
Yeti is a high-end brand that serves the needs of those who want the most premium quality items. If you can not compromise on the quality, style, and the shape of your cooler, which can be considered as smaller things as compared to the weight, insulation, and performance of the cooler, then you really need a wholistically good item such as the Yeti.
There are many other brands in the market that try to compete and compare themselves to the Yeti coolers. Here’s why they fail: because Yeti does not compete on its price or on the ice retention even, it competes on its brand value. Yeti seems expensive, it feels expensive and the brand is reserved for those with high taste. If you are one of those then it is the brand for you. If you are not conscious of the brand value or the taste then you can go for any brand of your choosing.
However, this does not mean that other brands like Orca and Pelican are not good enough. It does not even mean that their branding is not enough. It however does mean that they do not really focus on their own branding as the main functionality of the product.
Let’s further explore this yeti vs pelican coolers comparison table.
Pros about the Yeti Coolers:
Yeti Cooler is designed in a way to keep ice longer by insulating it twice than any other ice chest. It has impressive durability and ice retention than any separate water cooler available in the market. It’s great for hunting, sport-fishing, camping, boating, rafting, tailgating, paddling, and barbecuing. Its rotational modeling includes high temperature, low-pressure plastic forming processes that use heat and biaxial rotation. Its mold is made of polyethylene in powdered form. That gives more cooling wall thickness and a durable outside corner.
It claims that Yeti Cooler has high ice retention and can hold ice up to 10-14 days, depending on the type of ice. It is not even difficult to wash the Yeti Cooler; it’s easily cleaned with a high-pressure soapy spray found at a local do-it-yourself car wash.
Due to its robust model, there is no issue with stacking things up in a cooler. The drain plug is on the opposite end of the handle, so draining is as easy as loosening the drain plug and tilting the Haul using the handle. Yeti Cooler has a simple mission to provide, ice chest for everyday use if it exists. The cooler is the ultimate choice for outdoor enthusiasts, pros, tailgaters, and backyard barbecue kings.
Problems with the Yeti Coolers
Yeti Cooler is more expensive than other coolers available in the market. It is also on the heavier side, and it is 11 kg empty. It’s cumbersome and hard to move around, and when you start to fill it up with ice and food, it gets even heavier again. Latches that come in its model are challenging to use, especially for children.
They don’t understand the complicated design. Also, it’s the lid. It is substantial; it could be dangerous if it’s slipped. Although it’s ice retention is for 10-14 days, there are other brands available in the market that store ice for longer. Even the ice cooler must be prepared overnight before any long-distance travel so that it remains cold for longer times. The other problem with Yeti Cooler is it has insulation around the actual area to hold things.
Some of the popular Yeti coolers are:
Pros about the Pelican coolers:
Pelican is another more relaxed brand available in the market; its durability and versatility of design are remarkable. It has Puncture-resistant material to stand up to outdoor use. Lightweight design with padded shoulder straps for maximum portability and versatility.
The compression-molded base for increased structure and durability. Leak-resistant zipper with a waterproof seal to keep ice, and everything else where it belongs. High-density, closed-cell foam for extreme insulation. Exterior pocket to keep dry goods safe and secure.
It claims whether you are hunting, fishing, boating, camping, or out on a picnic, nothing will beat Pelican’s ice retention and indestructibility. It’s core sizes are up to 30% lighter than traditionally rotomolded coolers without sacrificing any durability and still being true to its full capacity. It is excellent for outdoor trips e.g., hikes and bike rides. It holds up to six snacks or more. It also has a robust design, and it is that tough that you can run over a truck, and it would be fine.
Problems with the Pelican Coolers
Pelican is expensive and can only hold ice up to 2 days max. The Pelican weighs a substantial amount more than other coolers of similar make and size. It also has a problem like Yeti Cooler to build ice way before it is used for longevity.
The Pelican cooler weighs approximately 33 lbs for the 35-Quart model. It gets heavier quickly when a few beverages and ice are added to it. It comes with a strap, and carrying this much weight on the shoulder doesn’t sound amazing.
Even its drainage spouse is made of cheap plastic, which fails over time due to outdoor heat. Some customers have gone as far as to use duct tape or their form of insulation just for the spout itself. That is a flaw in Pelican’s design. It has push-and-pull latches, it looks fancy, but when some dust and sand get into the mechanism, it doesn’t work correctly, This makes the Pelican coolers not wholly ideal for beach trips.
As far as length and weight go, the two are almost similar, with equivalent sizes being approximately equal. The Yeti is lighter though on the larger-sized 35 and 45 coolers by an average of 6-9 pounds. Certain distinctions include:
● Pelican uses hardware made of stainless steel, and Yeti uses aluminum.
● Pelican uses latches in 3 “Push & Pull and Yeti uses fasteners in rubber.
● Pelican is manufactured in the USA, and Yeti is produced in the Philippines and the USA.
● Both Pelican and Yeti are insulated from 2.00 “to 2.75” over their coolers.
Some of the popular Pelican coolers are given below.
Pelican Elite Coolers
Pelican Ruck R60
Pelican 20Q Elite Cooler
Which one is better:
Considering the ice retention of Yeti that is able to last for up to 6 days and the ice retention of the Pelican that is able to last for 2 days, you may clearly find yourself rooting for the Yeti cooler on top of the Pelican one. However, we want you to pause a moment and think about the duration of your trip, the number of people going, and the kind of trips that you usually take.
If you do not take a 6-day long trip then you do not need a Yeti cooler. If your cooler is not big enough to support the group members for the whole 6 days then as well it does not make sense that you buy a cooler that is going to stay cool for 6 days. It all depends on your planning and the usual trip style that you take normally.
To some people, the fight between Pelican coolers vs. Yeti would be a favorite, more refreshing brand. Nonetheless, you can prefer the Pelican brand cooler if you want a durable cooler with a lifetime warranty at a lower price. If your choice requires somewhat more spending on a prestigious tag, you may prefer the Yeti.
Pelican ProGear Elite is an excellent example of a Pelican Cooler. Maybe that will help you find out which one is best for you and your family. There isn’t too a difference between Pelican coolers and Yeti coolers, but you can expect a more extended warranty for one as compared to the other. You may prefer the handles of one product over the other too. And may also want one that has longer ice retention times as stated by the user.
These coolers can carry ice for five days, even though the summer is gone. Having seen the Pelican IM Elite retain ice for ten days+, we have to give the Pelican line of coolers a small advantage in terms of ice retention. Coolers Pelican is certainly bulkier than coolers Yeti Tundra. Unless you find the Pelican IM Exceptional in terms of weight/size, which is on par with the Tundra. Ultimately, the more affordable alternative is the Pelican line of coolers. So now it’s your choice which one seems more suitable to you, choose wisely.